Erie insurance agent mattoon il

Preston Insurance Agency IL

Affordable Coverage You Trust

Small Business Husband and Wife

WHY CHOOSE PRESTON INSURANCE

At Preston Insurance, our clients are our focus. We are proud to provide you with an experience that is more than just purchasing an insurance policy. We are dedicated to finding you the right coverage at the right price as well as looking ahead to anticipate your needs. Whether the services you need are for your home and auto or you’re in need of commercial insurance, we are committed to putting your needs first. We’re here to guide you through all of your insurance needs and build a relationship that you can trust.

Customer Service

We believe that our client comes first in all that we do. Providing an excellent experience is the cornerstone of our business.

Knowledge & Experience

With over 30 years in the insurance industry, our knowledgeable experts will guide you through each decision and ensure your understanding.

Local Friendly Neighbors

We love our community and our neighbors! We’re active in many aspects of the neighborhoods we live, work, and play in and would love to meet you!

Get Quote

“ Mike even came out to our home to help us with a flood issue even though he didn’t need to. Roxie was very diligent in shopping for affordable insurance for us when a company was looking to raise our rates. She contacted us beforehand to let us know so we could save money with better insurance. Great people to work with!”

“Doubled my car insurance and saved me $70!”

“Great insurance. Call them for all your insurance needs.”

“ Love Preston Insurance. Very professional service and they search for the best coverage at the best price!! I worked with them and couldn’t be happier. ”

“They are nice people who get the job done. I have compared prices. Theirs is the best.”

Our Partners

Insurance with a Personal Touch

Insuring your commercial or personal effects doesn’t have to be complicated. We’re here to help walk you through every aspect of coverage. As an independent agent, we provide you with multiple policy options tailored to you or your business and help you understand the benefits of each one. This leads to a stress-free, easy experience when securing insurance for your business, home, auto, RV, boat, and more.
Let’s start a conversation! Get a quote today!

Proud Members Of

Decatur Office
3795 N Woodford St, Decatur, IL 62526
(217) 876-8006

Springfield Office
3307 Robbins Rd, Springfield, IL 62704
(217) 529-9711

Peoria Office
2000 W Pioneer Pkwy #24, Peoria, IL 61615
(309) 688-0644

Lexington Office
Lexington, SC
(803) 414-8539

Divisions of Preston Insurance
Harmon Insurance
200 Western Ave, Abingdon, IL 61410
(309) 462-2305
Visit Harmon Insurance
Butler Insurance Agency
620 Lake Land Blvd., Mattoon, IL 61938
(217) 235-4096
Visit Butler Insurance Agency
Carney's Insurance Store
351 Sabella St. Pekin, IL 61554
(309) 347-2121